Court Says Simon Singh Can Claim 'Fair Comment' In Calling BCA Claims Bogus

from the that's not bogus dept

We’ve written a few times about the UK libel lawsuit brought by the British Chriropractor’s Association (BCA) against writer/scientist Simon Singh, because he called some of the BCA’s claims (concerning what chiropractic work can do) “bogus.” The courts had originally determined that the word “bogus” meant being deliberately dishonest and found him guilty of libel in a determination of how that word usage would be viewed at trial. In response, a large group of people have been ripping apart claims by the BCA with detailed analyses (stuff many in the press won’t touch for fear of being sued as well). The case had become so involved that Singh stopped writing his column to focus on the lawsuit.



Thankfully, there’s some good news, as the court has now decided that the original ruling was a mistake and Singh can use a defense of “fair comment” as the basis for his column. As such the trial will continue, but Singh is in a better position. Amazingly, despite all of this the BCA still wants to fight. At some point you wonder why they don’t just back down. The more they fight, the more people expose them for making, yes, bogus claims. Singh and others aren’t claiming that chiropractors don’t do any good — they’re just questioning some of the more extreme, and scientifically unsupported, claims made by the BCA. If the BCA were smart, they’d focus on improving their messaging, not fighting back.

Filed Under: , ,
Companies: bca

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Court Says Simon Singh Can Claim 'Fair Comment' In Calling BCA Claims Bogus”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
16 Comments

Witch Doctors

How about forcing then to preface Dr. with Witch?

Ronald J. Riley,

I am speaking only on my own behalf.
Affiliations:
President – http://www.PIAUSA.org – RJR at PIAUSA.org
Executive Director – http://www.InventorEd.org – RJR at InvEd.org
Senior Fellow – http://www.PatentPolicy.org
President – Alliance for American Innovation
Caretaker of Intellectual Property Creators on behalf of deceased founder Paul Heckel
Washington, DC
Direct (810) 597-0194 / (202) 318-1595 – 9 am to 8 pm EST.

scotesays:

Wrong, Singh was **never** "found guilty of libel".

“The courts had originally determined that the word “bogus” meant being deliberately dishonest, and found him guilty of libel.”

Wrong.

The determination by Mr. Justice Eady on the “meaning” of bogus and such was a preliminary determination of what the “facts” and law would be at trial, not a finding of guilt. The recent appeal reversed Mr. Justice Eady’s silly findings, including that “happily” meant “knowingly”.

The new ruling doesn’t dismiss the case, it just changes what facts will be tried. Now that the appeals court has decided that Singh was expressing opinion subject to fair comment defence not fact and that he never said that the BCA knowingly made false claims, his victory is almost assured.

Please review the Jack of Kent blog for full coverage:

http://jackofkent.blogspot.com/

The best part in the ruling was the citation of a US Appeals Court judge, who said:

“[Plaintiffs] cannot, by simply filing suit and crying ‘character assassination!’, silence those who hold divergent views, no matter how adverse those views may be to plaintiffs’ interests. Scientific controversies must be settled by the methods of science rather than by the methods of litigation. ? More papers, more discussion, better data, and more satisfactory models ? not larger awards of damages ? mark the path towards superior understanding of the world around us.”

Re: Wrong, Singh was **never** "found guilty of libel".

The determination by Mr. Justice Eady on the “meaning” of bogus and such was a preliminary determination of what the “facts” and law would be at trial, not a finding of guilt. The recent appeal reversed Mr. Justice Eady’s silly findings, including that “happily” meant “knowingly”.

Aha. Thanks for the update. I’ve clarified the post.

Re: The BCA can't afford to lose

“then just paying his costs so far would bankrupt them.”

I don’t like loser pays because I think it gives more advantage to those with deep pockets but in this case BCA going bankrupt, followed by regulation would be quite gratifying.

Ronald J. Riley,

I am speaking only on my own behalf.
Affiliations:
President – http://www.PIAUSA.org – RJR at PIAUSA.org
Executive Director – http://www.InventorEd.org – RJR at InvEd.org
Senior Fellow – http://www.PatentPolicy.org
President – Alliance for American Innovation
Caretaker of Intellectual Property Creators on behalf of deceased founder Paul Heckel
Washington, DC
Direct (810) 597-0194 / (202) 318-1595 – 9 am to 8 pm EST.

Paulsays:

It?s amazing that people today whether involved in health care or not that continue to deny the plausible mechanisms of chiropractic and demand its whole grounding be within an evidence base that is hard to apply yet blindly back goal orientated healthcare without evidence as long as it is practiced by ?medical? doctors.

What the Appeal Court determined is that scientific controversies should be settled by scientific debate rather than litigation and this would be preferential.

However the reality is there are people like Singh who do not study the evidence carefully to arrive at a reasonable opinion and then expect to relay this opinion, despite it being prejudiced, inciteful and ill informed, and expect it to be received as conclusive.

It?s a fine line and Simon Singh played it beautifully.

It is up to chiropractors to prove their claims.

Is this a BOC shill?

I made the mistake of going to a chiropractor about twenty years ago. She took xrays of me and they came out completely washed out. For readers who do not understand what this means, she exposed me to far too much radiation.

I have come into contact with quite a number of chiropractors over the years and had them try to BS me about what they could do. I think based on these experiences that there are quite a few quacks in the profession.

Ronald J. Riley,

I am speaking only on my own behalf.
Affiliations:
President – http://www.PIAUSA.org – RJR at PIAUSA.org
Executive Director – http://www.InventorEd.org – RJR at InvEd.org
Senior Fellow – http://www.PatentPolicy.org
President – Alliance for American Innovation
Caretaker of Intellectual Property Creators on behalf of deceased founder Paul Heckel
Washington, DC
Direct (810) 597-0194 / (202) 318-1595 – 9 am to 8 pm EST.

Ronald J Rileysays:

Chiropractic Claims Are Bogus

It is my hope that consumer protection agencies worldwide will now take notice of outrageous claims and force Chiropractors to quite claiming that they cane cure auto-immune illnesses and other claims which are not supported by hard evidence. This kind of clampdown would serve the public’s interest and it would be poetic justice if such came out of this case.

Ronald J. Riley,

I am speaking only on my own behalf.
Affiliations:
President – http://www.PIAUSA.org – RJR at PIAUSA.org
Executive Director – http://www.InventorEd.org – RJR at InvEd.org
Senior Fellow – http://www.PatentPolicy.org
President – Alliance for American Innovation
Caretaker of Intellectual Property Creators on behalf of deceased founder Paul Heckel
Washington, DC
Direct (810) 597-0194 / (202) 318-1595 – 9 am to 8 pm EST.

vivaelamorsays:

Re:

“I find it hilarious that you would suspect someone else as a shill. Didnt you see the signature with all the org’s that nobody gives a flying F that hes a member of? oh wait thats you, the whoriest whore in whoreland.”

Do you even know what shill means? Mr Riley may have some unpopular views around here but he is plainly not a shill because he discloses his affiliations. If he were lying about those affiliations in an effort to distance himself from other interested parties to which he is affiliated, then you might call him a shill. Given his disclosed affiliations I think it very unlikely he is being deceitful.

That said, I hate long signatures in informal writing.

Anonymoussays:

“If he were lying about those affiliations in an effort to distance himself from other interested parties to which he is affiliated, then you might call him a shill.”

That is not the definition of a shill,

“A shill is person who is paid to help another person or organization to sell goods or services. “

I believe he is a paid mouth for those organizations (even if its himself paying himself).

vivaelamorsays:

Re:

“I believe he is a paid mouth for those organizations (even if its himself paying himself).”

Oh, so you’re saying he’s a self promoter? Gee, why didn’t I guess that’s what you meant. Maybe because that’s not what his use of the word was and your use of the word is hardly contentious! Yeah, there’s absolutely no difference between being paid to anonymously promote a cause and doing so openly. I guess you weren’t altogether wrong, just disingenuous.

scotesays:

“However the reality is there are people like Singh who do not study the evidence carefully to arrive at a reasonable opinion and then expect to relay this opinion, despite it being prejudiced, inciteful and ill informed, and expect it to be received as conclusive.”

Meanwhile, back in reality, Dr. Simon Singh is co-author of the critically acclaimed Trick or Treatment: The Undeniable Facts about Alternative Medicine. Trick or Treatment is an examination of the scientific evidence regarding alternative medicine, which he co-wrote with the first academic professor of alternative medicine, Dr. Edzard Ernst. Dr. Singh has reviewed the evidence, and the evidence is that Chiropractic is based on a bogus, 19th century theory of vitalism created by a man who claimed that deafness, and essentially all disease, could be cured by working people’s backs to unblock the flow of life energy. This bogus theory of “subluxations” is still taught to this very day in Chiropractic colleges.

Most low back pain gets better on its own. When people are treated for something that gets better on its own they attribute the cure to the treatment rather than their own healing power. That is the primary reason people think that Chiropractic works. Studies have shown that Chiropractic is somewhat better than placebo at treating low back pain, but no more so than physical therapy. But Chiropractors claim to treat much more than low back pain, claims that are not supported by sound evidence. And that was what Singh was pointing out in his article–a fact that offends the BCA very much. Meanwhile, the Chiropractic theory of subluxations remains a modern example of witch doctoring.

Clearly, paul, you are projecting when it comes to your claims about other people lacking of knowledge.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...
Older Stuff
13:40 It's Great That Winnie The Pooh Is In The Public Domain; But He Should Have Been Free In 1982 (Or Earlier) (35)
12:06 Norton 360 Now Comes With Crypto Mining Capabilities And Sketchy Removal Process (28)
10:45 Chinese Government Dragnet Now Folding In American Social Media Platforms To Silence Dissent (14)
10:40 Daily Deal: The 2022 Ultimate Cybersecurity Analyst Preparation Bundle (0)
09:29 A Fight Between Facebook And The British Medical Journal Highlights The Difficulty Of Moderating 'Medical Misinformation' (9)
06:29 Court Ruling Paves The Way For Better, More Reliable Wi-Fi (4)
20:12 Eighth Circuit (Again) Says There's Nothing Wrong With Detaining Innocent Minors At Gunpoint (15)
15:48 China's Regulatory War On Its Gaming Industry Racks Up 14k Casualties (10)
13:31 Chinese Government Fines Local Car Dealerships For Surveilling While Not Being The Government (5)
12:08 Eric Clapton Pretends To Regret The Decision To Sue Random German Woman Who Listed A Bootleg Of One Of His CDs On Ebay (29)
10:44 ICE Is So Toxic That The DHS's Investigative Wing Is Asking To Be Completely Separated From It (29)
10:39 Daily Deal: The 2022 Complete Raspberry Pi And Arduino Developer Bundle (0)
09:31 Google Blocked An Article About Police From The Intercept... Because The Title Included A Phrase That Was Also A Movie Title (24)
06:22 Wireless Carriers Balk At FAA Demand For 5G Deployment Delays Amid Shaky Safety Concerns (16)
19:53 Tenth Circuit Denies Qualified Immunity To Social Worker Who Fabricated A Mother's Confession Of Child Abuse (35)
15:39 Sci-Hub's Creator Thinks Academic Publishers, Not Her Site, Are The Real Threat To Science, And Says: 'Any Law Against Knowledge Is Fundamentally Unjust' (34)
13:32 Federal Court Tells Proud Boys Defendants That Raiding The Capitol Building Isn't Covered By The First Amendment (25)
12:14 US Courts Realizing They Have A Judge Alan Albright Sized Problem In Waco (17)
10:44 Boston Police Department Used Forfeiture Funds To Hide Purchase Of Surveillance Tech From City Reps (16)
10:39 Daily Deal: The Ultimate Microsoft Excel Training Bundle (0)
09:20 NY Senator Proposes Ridiculously Unconstitutional Social Media Law That Is The Mirror Opposite Of Equally Unconstitutional Laws In Florida & Texas (25)
06:12 Telecom Monopolies Are Exploiting Crappy U.S. Broadband Maps To Block Community Broadband Grant Requests (7)
12:00 Funniest/Most Insightful Comments Of 2021 At Techdirt (17)
10:00 Gaming Like It's 1926: Join The Fourth Annual Public Domain Game Jam (6)
09:00 New Year's Message: The Arc Of The Moral Universe Is A Twisty Path (33)
19:39 DHS, ICE Begin Body Camera Pilot Program With Surprisingly Good Policies In Place (7)
15:29 Remembering Techdirt Contributors Sherwin And Elliot (1)
13:32 DC Metro PD's Powerful Review Panel Keeps Giving Bad Cops Their Jobs Back (6)
12:11 Missouri Governor Still Expects Journalists To Be Prosecuted For Showing How His Admin Leaked Teacher Social Security Numbers (39)
10:48 Oversight Board Overturning Instagram Takedown Of Ayahuasca Post Demonstrates The Impossibility Of Content Moderation (10)
More arrow
This site, like most other sites on the web, uses cookies. For more information, see our privacy policy. Got it