Austrian Collection Societies Want A 'You Must Be A Criminal' Tax On Hard Drives

from the pay-up dept

techflaws.org points us to the news that seven different collection societies in Austria are demanding a private copying levy on all hard drives (Google translation of the original German). Since seven different collection societies are involved, and each needs to get a cut, when you add all their fees up — it means that all hard drives under 500 GB have 21.60 euros added to the bill, while hard drives over 750 GB get a whopping 43.74 euros added (it’s not clear what happens between 500 to 750 GB). There’s also some weirdness where hardware vendors who give up their right to sue can have the levy reduced by 2/3 — which makes the whole thing seem even more sketchy. Apparently, similar plans have been rejected in the past, but the collection societies have claimed “times have changed.” And, the response should be: so it’s about time you learned to change as well.

Filed Under: , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Austrian Collection Societies Want A 'You Must Be A Criminal' Tax On Hard Drives”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
45 Comments
Anonymoussays:

Re: Re: Hard drive license

No. Think of it like paying for a road tax and speeding – http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/Motoring/OwningAVehicle/HowToTaxYourVehicle/DG_10012524

You own a car in the UK, you pay road tax. You speed and get caught you pay a fine, get points on your license, go to prison.

You buy a hard disk, you pay the “content owner” tax. You download copyrighted material without permission, you get fined (sued), lose your internet connection, go to prison.

This is commonly referred to as – having your cake and eating it.

Re: Re: Re: Re: Hard drive license

Actually, that’s not such a horrible analogy, but it doesn’t prove your point.

The road tax pays to support the upgrades and maintenance of the roads. In the case of hard drives, you’re already paying for that when you pay for the hard drive itself (without any tax involved).

If you speed you pay a fine – but you don’t pay that price if you follow the speed limit. In this analogy, you’re paying for a speeding ticket even if you don’t speed.

Let’s say a user doesn’t download any music (e.g. if it’s a hard drive for a private corporate server). Yet they still have to pay music collection agencies. How is that in any way justified?

The accurate analogy is: You have to pay a “speeding ticket” – whether you speed or not – no matter if you’re a car, a truck, a train, a plane, or simply crossing the border on foot.

Damiansays:

Okay, so they basically want to tax an information storage device. They’ve already gotten away with this in Canada, with the blank cd levy.
I wonder how this will work. In the European Union, you have the concept of free movement of goods i.e. you don’t have to pay import duty if its from one EU member to another. So, if I live in Austria and order a hard drive from Germany, do I have to pay a tax?
Plus, where will it stop? Are they eventually going to run out of devices to collect on, and then say, “Let’s tax paper too! People can write…oh…lemme think here…song lyrics! Yeah, lets go with that!”
Eventually, they will no longer be an entertainment industry. With all these taxes, they will no longer have the incentive to produce new content. They will just point at a device, say you and I owe them money because we might be pirates, and collect it. What would you do in their situation? Write a new song every once in a while, or release one, and collect a tax for it forever, regardless of the fact NO-ONE listens to your song?
Plus, how do these collection agencies determine how to split the money? Oh wait, I forget, they don’t. These agencies have been exposed in the past as keeping the money they collect.

Rikuosays:

Re: Re: Re: Re:

“It can be arranged the other way around – every HD sold in Austria (meaning by an Austrian company) will be taxed and the tax will be paid by the seller.”

The cost to the seller of paying this tax will then be tacked on to the selling price of the hard drive…so in the end, Average Austrian Joe still has to pay the tax.

Anonymoussays:

Re: Re:

Basically, in the case of the CD levy, it was pretty retarded, it applies to “audio recording media”, so the CD manufacturing companies made up stupid distinctions saying they sold CDs for copying music and CDs for copying data (that were of course actually the same thing) and if anyone was stupid enough to buy the CD that is advertised as being for music, they have to pay 5 times as much for it.

Sliding Scale?

I can’t get Google Translate to work but I wonder if the fees increase with the HD size or is it a flat fee for anything over 750GB. If its a flat fee, then you encourage people to purchase a larger hard drive to lower your per GB costs.

So they?re driving up the costs of hardware, not solving the “problem” of infringement, saying to the consumer you’re a criminal and this fee pays for your infringement which encourages more infringement, and making larger hard drives (to store all of the infringing files you paid for with this fee) more attractive.

This is a brilliant idea!! I?m sure it?s going to help them in the long run.

CNsays:

Where does it end?

Why doesn’t everyone else do it too?

They should have a Bank tax on guns, because some people use them to rob banks. Some people pretend to have guns in their pockets as well, so the tax should also extend to:

– pens
– pencils
– bananas
– toy guns
– fingers

Don’t forget other items such as knives, baseball bats, golf clubs. And a car tax, since getaways are often made in cars.

I’m sure there’s more. Convenience stores should also be able to get a cut.

Some people don’t pick up after their dogs when they go. Just fine everyone with a dog, much simpler than going after the actual offenders.

I could go on, but I think the point is made.

Anonymoussays:

Re: Re: Re: Re: Hungary is a Paradise

Ahh, I forgot to mention that you also have to pay for mp3 players and certain cellphones. And if you want to turn on the radio in your shop. The next step is getting a levy on thinking about music.

And who likes it? Those people, who convinced the politicians in the early 1990’s that this is necessary, and they get this neat association which has legal power to decide how much you have to pay. The minister for culture is always their puppet. Nobody would pay for their 10 holidays a year otherwise.

ps. There is a single good thing in this mess: you can download music/movies etc. for private use. But what is the price? You have to pay the fee for a memory card which you are using in your camera.

MACsays:

Hard drive tax

So, lets tax memory sticks, SD cards, where will it all end?

Politicians and bureaucrats will come up with even more creative ways to tax.

Hey, your brain is like a hard drive, so why don’t we tax it’s storage capacity?

Let’s see, 2 trillion billion neurons… Hmmm… It should be a fee of about $500,000. So, let’s span that out over say a 75 year lifetime and voila! You pay $6,661 a year because some copyrighted song that you despise might be playing in your head and some idiot thinks you are violating some bozos rights to rip us off as much as they possibly can.

By the way, I work for a label and I believe in giving the devil his due but this is getting downright ridiculous.

Anonymoussays:

The same system (with basically the same rates) is already in place in Italy since January 2010. Italian people have started buying hard-drives from Austria and Germany.

There is even a litte black market of non-imported-in-Italy-but-somewhere-in-the-EU disks sold in small shops. This is barely legal but can save you 20 or 30 euro on a disk that costs 80 euro.

And no, you do not get to download what you want.

And to add insult to injury, the levy is given to only one collection society that shares it only with the top-40 musicians of the last year. No video, no independant authors, no one else.

NAMELESS.ONEsays:

talk to Stepehen Harper

he says the gun registry treats people like criminals for registering something THAT CAN KILL people…now maybe if he dont want that he don’t want new copyright bill in canada and won’t sign ACTA…

up next for real is the copyright law bill c32 in canada even stricter then the DMCA and ACTA treaty….
end of the net and it will mean as people catch on LOADS just dropping it

The Canadian Levy was bad

In Canada most Canadians believe that the Levy means we can copy copyright music onto our CDs. This is not actually stated in our existing law however. As I understand it, the levy money has been collected by copyright collectives, most likely the ones quoted on this GRAMMY article. It’s pretty scary when people believe that copyright law is supposed to “to provide a new marketplace for creators.”

I’ve heard that the Canadian Levy is supposed to be paid out under the radio play formula. I’ve never seen anything definitively saying that creators have gotten paid out of the money that’s been collected. The result has been that CD’s have become more expensive than DVDs. The justification is that it is supposed to help finance creators, but if it helps anyone outside of the copyright collectives, it’s the Top 40 as suggested by Anonymous Coward.

The actual Independent musicians, the ones who it ought to be for, the ones who actually distribute their music online and don’t appear on the radio, not only don’t get a piece of the action, they have to pay the levy when they are burning CDs to sell (or even promos to give away!)

Many Canadians believe that the Levy means we can copy movies as well.

There was a suggestion by Charlie Angus, the one Canadian politician who seems to understand this stuff, that the CD Levy should be expanded to cover all storage devices. Our Minister of Heritage (who blocks citizens from following his Twitter feed) very emphatically said that this “ipod tax” was not going to happen.

Meanwhile our current government is attempting to put through Bill C-32, a new copyright law (which appears to have been written by the MPAA/RIAA/USTR/CRIA) that will be worse than the DMCA as suggested by NAMELESS.ONE. When they aren’t doing that, they keep ACTAing along.

In Soviet Russia

I live in Russia and want you to know that we have similar problems here.
Russian Collecting Society (RAO) and Nikita Mikhalkov’s Russian Union of Right-holders (RUR) are now in the battle for the Grand-Prix of Copyright — the right to legally collect the already infamous copyright tax from all importers of blank CDs, HDDs, flash drives, electronic devices (MP3 and DVD players, cell phones, etc.), computers and whatnot. The estimated amount of fees is about $100 million a year. This includes 1% tax on the imported devices and 3% tax on blank drives.
The two contenders claim they’re acting in accordance with the Civil Code. They are awaiting a decision by the Rosokhrankultura, Russian government’s “culture heritage” protection agency, that has to choose, which organization is to reap the benefits.
Read more here: http://j.mp/9EfJIw (Google Translation).

Spain

This has been done in Spain for a long while, we pay our RIAA equivalent a small fee of all mp3 players/storage devices/CD/DVD’s. The ‘good’ point?

In a series of cases, Spanish courts have ruled that file sharing for private use is legal. In 2006, the record industry’s attempt to criminalize file sharing were disappointed when Judge Paz Aldecoa declared it legal to download indiscriminately in Spain, if done for private use and without any profit purpose.

Taken from this wikipedia entry.

The small thought of “well, they deserve some money from what they have produced” is gone, as they are already taking money from me.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop ยป

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Report this ad??|??Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...
Older Stuff
12:25 Australian Privacy Commissioner Says 7-Eleven Broke Privacy Laws By Scanning Customers' Faces At Survey Kiosks (6)
10:50 Missouri Governor Doubles Down On 'View Source' Hacking Claim; PAC Now Fundraising Over This Bizarrely Stupid Claim (45)
10:45 Daily Deal: The All-in-One Microsoft, Cybersecurity, And Python Exam Prep Training Bundle (0)
09:43 Want To Understand Why U.S. Broadband Sucks? Look At Frontier Communications In Wisconsin, West Virginia (8)
05:36 Massachusetts College Decides Criticizing The Chinese Government Is Hate Speech, Suspends Conservative Student Group (71)
19:57 Le Tigre Sues Barry Mann To Stop Copyright Threats Over Song, Lights Barry Mann On Fire As Well (21)
16:07 Court Says City Of Baltimore's 'Heckler's Veto' Of An Anti-Catholic Rally Violates The First Amendment (15)
13:37 Two Years Later, Judge Finally Realizes That A CDN Provider Is Not Liable For Copyright Infringement On Websites (21)
12:19 Chicago Court Gets Its Prior Restraint On, Tells Police Union Head To STFU About City's Vaccine Mandate (158)
10:55 Verizon 'Visible' Wireless Accounts Hacked, Exploited To Buy New iPhones (8)
10:50 Daily Deal: The MacOS 11 Course (0)
07:55 Suing Social Media Sites Over Acts Of Terrorism Continues To Be A Losing Bet, As 11th Circuit Dumps Another Flawed Lawsuit (11)
02:51 Trump Announces His Own Social Network, 'Truth Social,' Which Says It Can Kick Off Users For Any Reason (And Already Is) (100)
19:51 Facebook AI Moderation Continues To Suck Because Moderation At Scale Is Impossible (26)
16:12 Content Moderation Case Studies: Snapchat Disables GIPHY Integration After Racist 'Sticker' Is Discovered (2018) (11)
13:54 Arlo Makes Live Customer Service A Luxury Option (8)
12:05 Delta Proudly Announces Its Participation In The DHS's Expanded Biometric Collection Program (5)
11:03 LinkedIn (Mostly) Exits China, Citing Escalating Demands For Censorship (14)
10:57 Daily Deal: The Python, Git, And YAML Bundle (0)
09:37 British Telecom Wants Netflix To Pay A Tax Simply Because Squid Game Is Popular (32)
06:41 Report: Client-Side Scanning Is An Insecure Nightmare Just Waiting To Be Exploited By Governments (35)
20:38 MLB In Talks To Offer Streaming For All Teams' Home Games In-Market Even Without A Cable Subscription (10)
15:55 Appeals Court Says Couple's Lawsuit Over Bogus Vehicle Forfeiture Can Continue (15)
13:30 Techdirt Podcast Episode 301: Scarcity, Abundance & NFTs (0)
12:03 Hollywood Is Betting On Filtering Mandates, But Working Copyright Algorithms Simply Don't Exist (66)
10:45 Introducing The Techdirt Insider Discord (4)
10:40 Daily Deal: The Dynamic 2021 DevOps Training Bundle (0)
09:29 Criminalizing Teens' Google Searches Is Just How The UK's Anti-Cybercrime Programs Roll (19)
06:29 Canon Sued For Disabling Printer Scanners When Devices Run Out Of Ink (41)
20:51 Copyright Law Discriminating Against The Blind Finally Struck Down By Court In South Africa (7)
More arrow