Producers Of '50 Shades' Porn Parody Argue That The Work Is In The Public Domain… But It's Not

from the that's-not-how-the-law-works dept

Back when Universal Studios sued the makers of a “porn parody” of the insanely popular book 50 Shades of Grey, we were among those who pointed out that the book itself was really originally a fan fiction work based on the Twilight books/movie series, and that it seemed a bit hypocritical to not allow other derivative works. I don’t know if it was because of us calling out this fact, but the producers, Smash Pictures, are using that exact point in their defense… but then are bizarrely arguing that this makes the work in the public domain.


On information and belief, as much as 89% of the content of the
allegedly copyrighted materials grew out of a multi-part series of fan fiction
called Masters of the Universe based on Stephenie Myer’s Twilight novels. On
information and belief, this content was published online between 2009 and 2011
in various venues, including fanfiction.net and the person website of Erika
Leonard. On information and belief, much or all of this material was placed in
the public domain.

To which we can only say, “huh?!?” I could see an argument being made about transformative works and fair use, but there’s no indication anywhere that the work is in the public domain. Just because the same author posted a very similar version online earlier has no bearing on the copyright in the work itself. It kind of makes you wonder about the lawyer that Smash Pictures has working on this case that they’d even make this argument.

Not surprisingly, Universal Studio’s high priced lawyers hit back pretty quickly, calling the filing “slapped-together” and pointing out that the whole public domain argument makes no sense.


Moreover, their unsupported assertion that “as
much as 89% of the allegedly copyrighted material is derived from previously
published, public domain fan fiction based on Stephanie Myers’ Twilight novels”
is both deliberately misleading and legally flawed. Defendants suggest
that the Fifty Shades Trilogy is “derived from” works by authors other than Erika
Mitchell. However, Defendants are in fact referring to an earlier version of the
same story written by Ms. Mitchell, which they in their own improper deposition
notice identified as “Master of the Universe.” ….. Defendants do
not and cannot provide any legal authority for the proposition that an earlier
version of Ms. Mitchell’s work is now in the “public domain.” They can hardly
defend their infringement of Plaintiffs’ copyrights in the Fifty Shades Trilogy by
claiming that it is substantially similar to Ms. Mitchell’s own earlier work.

Indeed. While I still think the lawsuit itself is silly, the public domain claim here is just wacky.





Filed Under: , , , , , , , ,
Companies: smash pictures, universal studios

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “Producers Of '50 Shades' Porn Parody Argue That The Work Is In The Public Domain… But It's Not”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
12 Comments
PTsays:

Re: Re: The one book you can't do a porn parody of

Indeed. And the notion that “Fifty Shades” is in any way derivative of stories about a woman who stubbornly refuses to have sex until she’s legally wed beggars belief. The only thing “Fifty Shades” has in common with “Twilight” is a naive heroine.

Beechsays:

Re: Re: The one book you can't do a porn parody of

So now you can’t do a porn parody of a porn parody? Maybe it would be some kind of meta-porn.

What would be really funny is if they did a PG parody of 50 shades. Have the hammy porn acting, get the actors into really hot and steamy situations…only to have them remember they have somewhere else to be and walk away. The audience would be waiting for nudity, and it would never come (pun intended i guess?).

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Report this ad??|??Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...
Older Stuff
12:25 Australian Privacy Commissioner Says 7-Eleven Broke Privacy Laws By Scanning Customers' Faces At Survey Kiosks (6)
10:50 Missouri Governor Doubles Down On 'View Source' Hacking Claim; PAC Now Fundraising Over This Bizarrely Stupid Claim (45)
10:45 Daily Deal: The All-in-One Microsoft, Cybersecurity, And Python Exam Prep Training Bundle (0)
09:43 Want To Understand Why U.S. Broadband Sucks? Look At Frontier Communications In Wisconsin, West Virginia (8)
05:36 Massachusetts College Decides Criticizing The Chinese Government Is Hate Speech, Suspends Conservative Student Group (71)
19:57 Le Tigre Sues Barry Mann To Stop Copyright Threats Over Song, Lights Barry Mann On Fire As Well (21)
16:07 Court Says City Of Baltimore's 'Heckler's Veto' Of An Anti-Catholic Rally Violates The First Amendment (15)
13:37 Two Years Later, Judge Finally Realizes That A CDN Provider Is Not Liable For Copyright Infringement On Websites (21)
12:19 Chicago Court Gets Its Prior Restraint On, Tells Police Union Head To STFU About City's Vaccine Mandate (158)
10:55 Verizon 'Visible' Wireless Accounts Hacked, Exploited To Buy New iPhones (8)
10:50 Daily Deal: The MacOS 11 Course (0)
07:55 Suing Social Media Sites Over Acts Of Terrorism Continues To Be A Losing Bet, As 11th Circuit Dumps Another Flawed Lawsuit (11)
02:51 Trump Announces His Own Social Network, 'Truth Social,' Which Says It Can Kick Off Users For Any Reason (And Already Is) (100)
19:51 Facebook AI Moderation Continues To Suck Because Moderation At Scale Is Impossible (26)
16:12 Content Moderation Case Studies: Snapchat Disables GIPHY Integration After Racist 'Sticker' Is Discovered (2018) (11)
13:54 Arlo Makes Live Customer Service A Luxury Option (8)
12:05 Delta Proudly Announces Its Participation In The DHS's Expanded Biometric Collection Program (5)
11:03 LinkedIn (Mostly) Exits China, Citing Escalating Demands For Censorship (14)
10:57 Daily Deal: The Python, Git, And YAML Bundle (0)
09:37 British Telecom Wants Netflix To Pay A Tax Simply Because Squid Game Is Popular (32)
06:41 Report: Client-Side Scanning Is An Insecure Nightmare Just Waiting To Be Exploited By Governments (35)
20:38 MLB In Talks To Offer Streaming For All Teams' Home Games In-Market Even Without A Cable Subscription (10)
15:55 Appeals Court Says Couple's Lawsuit Over Bogus Vehicle Forfeiture Can Continue (15)
13:30 Techdirt Podcast Episode 301: Scarcity, Abundance & NFTs (0)
12:03 Hollywood Is Betting On Filtering Mandates, But Working Copyright Algorithms Simply Don't Exist (66)
10:45 Introducing The Techdirt Insider Discord (4)
10:40 Daily Deal: The Dynamic 2021 DevOps Training Bundle (0)
09:29 Criminalizing Teens' Google Searches Is Just How The UK's Anti-Cybercrime Programs Roll (19)
06:29 Canon Sued For Disabling Printer Scanners When Devices Run Out Of Ink (41)
20:51 Copyright Law Discriminating Against The Blind Finally Struck Down By Court In South Africa (7)
More arrow