FCC's Ajit Pai: By Making Sure The Internet Is Open And Free… It Will Inspire North Korea And Cuba To Censor

from the say-what-now? dept

I should note, upfront, that I’ve had the chance to meet FCC Commissioner Ajit Pai a couple of times, and always found him to be interesting and knowledgeable, as well as engaged on important issues. Yet, for whatever reason, when it comes to net neutrality issues, the former Verizon lawyer (clue number 1) seems to have gone off the deep end, tossed all logic and intellectual honesty out the window, in an effort to just lash out angrily with whatever he’s got. We’ve talked about his incoherent attack on Netflix and his sudden and newfound love of transparency (never noted before…).

But his latest move just strips whatever credibility he may have had on the subject completely away. He’s insisting that the FCC’s new net neutrality rules (which he opposes) will inspire North Korea and Iran to further control and censor the internet (which they already control and heavily censor). And he’s not arguing this in a “they hate us for our freedom” way, but he’s actively lying and claiming that this move — a move to guarantee openness and not censorship online — will give the North Korean and Iranian governments the political cover to censor the internet. Let’s be frank, Pai’s statements are complete nonsense.


“If in the United States we adopt regulations that assert more government control over how the Internet operates … it becomes a lot more difficult for us to go on the international stage and tell governments: ‘Look, we want you to keep your hands off the internet,’” he said.

“Even if the ideas aren’t completely identical, you can appreciate the optical difficult in trying to make that case,” he added.

Except, uh, the “rules” being described are ones that just say “the internet needs to be open and free from interference, censorship and discrimination.” I don’t see how anyone could legitimately claim this will somehow undermine a message of internet freedom. But watch Pai work himself up into a moral panic over a complete misrepresentation of what’s happening:


In the background, meanwhile, countries such as North Korea and Cuba are trying to exact more control of the Internet through an arm of the United Nations called the International Telecommunication Union, he warned.

Nations such as Turkey and China are also enacting new controls in their own countries and “testing the waters to see how much they can get away with,” Pai said.

“I think the U.S.-based system of Internet governance has served us very well and I hope we don’t do anything to jeopardize that in the near future.”

He’s right that there are questions about internet governance — and we’ve covered the various discussions on that for a while now. But the FCC’s rules to protect an open and free internet is not about “internet governance” or Cuba or North Korea censoring the internet at all. It takes a special kind of desperation to try to argue that preserving an open and free internet is actually about telling oppressive authoritarian regimes that it’s okay to censor and lock down the internet. No one believes it at all, and it just takes away whatever credibility Pai may have had on the subject.

Filed Under: , , , , , , ,

Rate this comment as insightful
Rate this comment as funny
You have rated this comment as insightful
You have rated this comment as funny
Flag this comment as abusive/trolling/spam
You have flagged this comment
The first word has already been claimed
The last word has already been claimed
Insightful Lightbulb icon Funny Laughing icon Abusive/trolling/spam Flag icon Insightful badge Lightbulb icon Funny badge Laughing icon Comments icon

Comments on “FCC's Ajit Pai: By Making Sure The Internet Is Open And Free… It Will Inspire North Korea And Cuba To Censor”

Subscribe: RSS Leave a comment
26 Comments
leehb9says:

Re: Re: God help us....

From the ‘Don’t-cha-know’ department: The first and most important quality for a government employee is to be totally ‘clueless’ about everything.

Anyone with any real brains would be a direct threat to his/her fellow employees and most especially to the management staff. Thus, we get guys like the moron in this article..

And regarding the subject of this reply, we’re beyond his/her help now.

‘Help me, Obiwan Kenobi…’

Anonymoussays:

Pot, meet kettle

I find it disturbing that he criticizes Cuba, China, & North Korea for not having a free and open Internet, while his own country scoops up all communications by default, in case of insert boogeyman of the day here

Commissioner Pai should ask himself: Is a “free and open Internet” one where the government has access to all the information that crosses it?
Because I for one, do not see that as free, nor open.

Anonymoussays:

There would have been no issue with Title II coming up at the FCC except for one little item. Verizon decided to take the FCC to court over the idea it did not have a mandate from congress to enforce net neutrality. It won it’s case.

So the FCC will now look to implement Title II as a way to enforce net neutrality where it does have a mandate. This became necessary when the major telcoms started a ‘nice business you have there Netflix’ of wanting Neftlix to pay for what those telcoms had already been paid for by it’s customers. This happened within a week of Verizon winning it’s court case.

The telcoms have no reason to bitch, having brought this on themselves. Commissioner Pai has lost before he’s started on this one as the actions and evidence speaks for itself on what will happen without Title II.

gorehoundsays:

Republicans are Slimeballs

This man is a Republican and he is a slimeball like the rest of them.
GOP are full of hateful people, greedbags like Pai, bigots, Jesus Freaks, control freaks………….sick and tired of this Party.The Day it dies I will celebrate.Every day of the week I can easily find at least 3 News pieces on the doing something really hateful towards others.For years now this has gone on…………..the old Republican Party is long dead and the new one is full of extremists who ram thru their views on the rest of us.

Most Dems support Net Neutrality…a few of them won’t and will take the money.
Most GOP support creating a toll road and fleecing the public…and if it happens this is going to be exported to the greater World .I can see the rest of the World forced into a toll road as well.
Obama is a Dem and he went out to state his position on Net Neutrality….the GOP do the opposite.

And then you got the assholes like CRUZ who says it is like Obamacare for the Net and we all know the brain dead GOP followers lap that stuff right up (of course they do not understand how to even look at Win Explorer) .

naschsays:

Re: Re: Re: Re: Republicans are Slimeballs

Actually most Republican voters support Net Neutrality when asked.

When asked properly, anyway. If you ask them “do you support the FCC regulating ISPs under Title II” you’ll probably get a lot of no’s. If you ask “do you support regulation requiring ISPs to treat all internet traffic equally”, that’s probably what they would answer yes to. I don’t actually have any data, I’m just speaking from general knowledge of how the phrasing of survey questions affects the outcome. If anyone has links to specifics, let’s check it out.

Chronno S. Triggersays:

Well, he’s kinda right. Title II will inspire North Korea and other dictatorship countries to censor harder.

A free and open Internet will put more and more information out there. More information might inspire citizens of not so free countries to desire some of that freedom. Citizens who want freedom are the bane of totalitarians, thus they will censor.

But something that pisses off totalitarians and inspires citizens of totalitarian governments is a good thing, isn’t it?

Tazinatorsays:

Can see what his attempted argument is but it fails badly...

I can see what he is trying to say, that essentially if we put the companies that control net access under US government regulation that the oppressive countries which…already do censor their connections to their citizens will then have the ability to claim “We’re doing this because the US Govt controls the Internet!”

Problem 1:

He is throwing out how the Internet actually functions. If you disconnected the US from the rest of the net (which sadly some a-holes in DC attempted to do with SOPA and CISPA effectively creating a “Great Firewall” to control piracy…), the Internet would still exist and function albeit smaller and with a lot less websites. The whole concept and design of it negates any one country from controlling the entirety of it.

Problem 2:

On the front of country dictators having more excuses with Title II classification; that would be hypocritical for the simple fact that the ISPs of those nations are STATE OWNED AND REGULATED themselves. How can one say that “well the Internet is now in control of a government so we need to censor it” when their own governments control citizen access already.

Problem 3:

Oppressive countries already use the excuse that the US influences the net and thats why they regulate the access of their populations. Title II is going to do nothing to solidify that claim because ISPs are already government regulated (…though very lightly and with much favoritism thanks to the best lobbyists money can buy and the nonsense “Information Service” classification…).

All in all though his whole rambling nonsense ignores the fact that dictators will find an excuse to censor their people from the online world regardless of whatever we do to regulate ISPs. That is why they are dictators.

It really is an act of desperation to use this far reaching attempt at justification because it has absolutely no merit. It’s disgusting to see what a mess agencies which were designed to work for the people have become thanks to lobbyist and friendship appointments by politicians. Holding an appointment at an agency that is set to regulate and watchdog an industry you once lobbied for should be an automatic disqualification, no exceptions. Since it isn’t, we get idiots like this guy…

He does score points on how many logical fallacies he can shove into one statement:

https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/false-cause
https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/appeal-to-emotion
https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/personal-incredulity
even a little bit of https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/slippery-slope in there I think

Probably a few more can be pulled from his words too, but Im bored now…

naschsays:

Re: Re: Can see what his attempted argument is but it fails badly...

I can see what he is trying to say, that essentially if we put the companies that control net access under US government regulation

Even that much is misleading, because it’s not as though they’re unregulated now. This would be a change of regulation, but not adding regulations where there are currently none.

Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a Techdirt Account? Sign in now. Want one? Register here

Comment Options:

Make this the or (get credits or sign in to see balance) what's this?

What's this?

Techdirt community members with Techdirt Credits can spotlight a comment as either the "First Word" or "Last Word" on a particular comment thread. Credits can be purchased at the Techdirt Insider Shop »

Follow Techdirt

Techdirt Daily Newsletter

Techdirt Deals
Report this ad??|??Hide Techdirt ads
Techdirt Insider Discord
The latest chatter on the Techdirt Insider Discord channel...
Loading...
Older Stuff
06:31 DOJ Drops Ridiculous Trump-Era Lawsuit Against California For Passing Net Neutrality Rules (13)
06:27 The Wall Street Journal Kisses Big Telecom's Ass In Whiny Screed About 'Big Tech' (13)
10:45 New Interim FCC Boss Jessica Rosenworcel Will Likely Restore Net Neutrality, Just Not Yet (5)
15:30 Small Idaho ISP 'Punishes' Twitter And Facebook's 'Censorship' ... By Blocking Access To Them Entirely (81)
05:29 A Few Reminders Before The Tired Net Neutrality Debate Is Rekindled (13)
06:22 U.S. Broadband Speeds Jumped 90% in 2020. But No, It Had Nothing To Do With Killing Net Neutrality. (12)
12:10 FCC Ignores The Courts, Finalizes Facts-Optional Repeal Of Net Neutrality (19)
10:46 It's Opposite Day At The FCC: Rejects All Its Own Legal Arguments Against Net Neutrality To Claim It Can Be The Internet Speech Police (13)
12:05 Blatant Hypocrite Ajit Pai Decides To Move Forward With Bogus, Unconstitutional Rulemaking On Section 230 (175)
06:49 FCC's Pai Puts Final Bullet In Net Neutrality Ahead Of Potential Demotion (22)
06:31 The EU Makes It Clear That 'Zero Rating' Violates Net Neutrality (5)
06:22 DOJ Continues Its Quest To Kill Net Neutrality (And Consumer Protection In General) In California (11)
11:08 Hypocritical AT&T Makes A Mockery Of Itself; Says 230 Should Be Reformed For Real Net Neutrality (26)
06:20 Trump, Big Telecom Continue Quest To Ban States From Protecting Broadband Consumers (19)
06:11 Senators Wyden And Markey Make It Clear AT&T Is Violating Net Neutrality (13)
06:31 Net Neutrali-what? AT&T's New Streaming Service Won't Count Against Its Broadband Caps. But Netflix Will. (24)
06:23 Telecom's Latest Dumb Claim: The Internet Only Works During A Pandemic Because We Killed Net Neutrality (49)
13:36 Ex-FCC Staffer Says FCC Authority Given Up In Net Neutrality Repeal Sure Would Prove Handy In A Crisis (13)
06:27 Clarence Thomas Regrets Brand X Decision That Paved Way For The Net Neutrality Wars (11)
06:17 The FCC To Field More Comments On Net Neutrality. Maybe They'll Stop Identity Theft And Fraud This Time? (78)
08:56 AT&T, Comcast Dramatically Cut Network Spending Despite Net Neutrality Repeal (16)
06:18 Ajit Pai Hits CES... To Make Up Some Shit About Net Neutrality (24)
06:24 Mozilla, Consumer Groups Petition For Rehearing of Net Neutrality Case (22)
06:49 AT&T Exec Insists That No Broadband Company Is Violating Net Neutrality Even Though AT&T Is Absolutely Violating Net Neutrality (18)
06:45 Shocker: ISPs Cut Back 2020 Investment Despite Tax Breaks, Death Of Net Neutrality (61)
06:28 Ajit Pai Whines About The Numerous State-Level Net Neutrality Laws He Just Helped Create (47)
06:37 States Rush To Protect Net Neutrality On Heels Of Court Ruling (19)
06:21 Former FCC Boss Wheeler Says New Court Ruling Won't Stop Net Neutrality (14)
10:50 Court Says FCC Can't Stop States From Protecting Net Neutrality (63)
09:37 One More Time: Just Because The Internet Didn't Explode Doesn't Mean Killing Net Neutrality Was A Great Idea (45)
More arrow