How Steak-umm Became The Tweeting Voice Of Reason In A Pandemic
from the content-is-advertising dept
Many, many years ago I wrote about the importance of recognizing that content is advertising and advertising is content. A key point I was making was that these were not redundant. Good advertising should be good content to make people happy to see it. But also, any kind of good content can be good advertising for something else. I was reminded of this last week after seeing the Twitter account of Steak-umm suddenly become one of the best Twitter accounts to follow during the pandemic. To be honest, my last experience with Steam-umm, the frozen meat company, probably goes back to watching a commercial like this in 1982:
Those commercials were on all the time when I was a kid, but I don’t think I ever got to experience the actual joy (?!?) of eating a Steak-umm. And for that we can blame my parents. However, perhaps I’ll now give Steak-umm a shot, since watching its Twitter account actually become “the voice of reason in a pandemic.”
It started on April 6th with a pretty damn good tweet thread about not falling for anecdotal reports, and looking for thoughtful, detailed studies:
friendly reminder in times of uncertainty and misinformation: anecdotes are not data. (good) data is carefully measured and collected information based on a range of subject-dependent factors, including, but not limited to, controlled variables, meta-analysis, and randomization
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
outliers attempting to counter global consensus around this pandemic with amateur reporting or unverified sourcing are not collecting data. breaking news stories that only relay initial findings of an event are not collecting data. we have to be careful in our media consumption
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
it can be difficult to know what to believe in a time when institutional trust is diminished and the gatekeepers of information have been dismantled, but it's more crucial now than ever before to follow a range of credentialed sources for both breaking news and data collection
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
all we currently have are limited and evolving metrics that experts are deciphering and acting upon immediately to the best of their ability. this terrain leaves many openings for opportunists and charismatic manipulators to lead people astray by exploiting what they want to hear
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
breaking news and storytelling will always be spun with interpretive bias from different media perspectives, but data is a science that can't be replaced by one-off anecdotes. try to remember this to avoid fear-based sensationalism or conspiracy theories taking over your mind
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
you can maintain independent, critical thinking toward institutions without dipping into fringe conspiracies that get jumpstarted by individual anecdotes being virally spread as data. it's not easy, but it's necessary to keep any semblance of responsible online information flow
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
we're a frozen meat brand posting ads inevitably made to misdirect people and generate sales, so this is peak irony, but hey we live in a society so please make informed decisions to the best of your ability and don't let anecdotes dictate your worldview ok
steak-umm bless
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 7, 2020
I mean, even that self-aware final tweet is kind of pitch perfect for this kind of thing. Apparently the person behind all this is Nathan Allebach, who runs a communications shop that manages Steak-umm’s feed and decided he’d had enough of all the misinformation he was seeing. According to an interview he gave Fast Company:
?It was more just a cumulative effect of me having a job to spend every moment on social, seeing a constant flow of information, and a lot of it wasn?t good information,? says Nathan Allebach of the agency Allebach Communications, who has been the human behind Steak-Umm?s social media since 2015. Despite the thread being posted at 10 p.m., Allebach says it wasn?t prompted by a specific moment or piece of news. ?I know we?re in this state of panic, and heightened cultural anxiety, so people aren?t at their best all the time, thinking about where they?re getting their information.?
He’s since followed it up with a few other somewhat philosophical threads on all of this — including opining on the nature of its own tweets going viral:
people think it's bizarre, ironic, and funny when a frozen meat company points out the importance of critical thinking, but chances are the same message would never "go viral" if it was from a person. our society values entertainment over truth and that's a huge problem
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 8, 2020
Then there was another long thread on the difference between “experts” and “communicators” allowing factual information to be “spun.”
one major roadblock in getting credible information to the masses is the divide between experts and communicators. most experts aren't communicators and most communicators aren't experts. this often results in research being spun with a narrative by the time it reaches the public
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 9, 2020
And then another long thread about why people believe in conspiracy theories and how to respond to those believers:
just gonna come out and say it: vulnerable people are always the most susceptible to propaganda, misinformation, and conspiracy, especially in times of cultural anxiety, and if there is a way to help them out of these traps, targeted self-righteous vilification isn?t it
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 10, 2020
It is fantastic content — whether or not it sells any frozen meat. And even Steak-umm seems to recognize this:
we are just a frozen meat brand tweeting into the void hoping to provoke thought, inspire unity, and relay useful information. we are not an expert in anything or some beef god. we are a company with a bottom line being run by people. stay safe and be good to each other out there
— Steak-umm (@steak_umm) April 10, 2020
As is pretty much always the case, what’s amazing about this and what’s catching people’s attention is not just the fact that a frozen sliced meat company is tweeting about these things, but that it’s doing so earnestly, even while clearly recognizing the absurdity of it being the sudden tweeting fountain of wisdom. But that’s actually really important. In a time when cynicism, irony, and just everyday sarcasm seem to be the way plenty of people are dealing with this new incredibly uncertain age, having a bit of calm (if slightly tongue-in-cheek) earnestness is truly welcome. And if it helps sell more frozen meat, why, that would probably be a nice side benefit for the company.
Filed Under: advertising is content, content is advertising, covid-19, frozen meat, nathan allebach, native content, steak-umm
Companies: allebach communications, steak-umm, twitter
Comments on “How Steak-umm Became The Tweeting Voice Of Reason In A Pandemic”
Sincerity, even from a corporate branded Twitter account, beats irony every day of the week.
If Trump were CEO here, this advertising exec would be fired
It does not matter whether or not the media buzz sells steak. A Trumpish CEO would resent any attention not directed to him personally.
Re: If Trump were CEO here, this advertising exec would be fired
I think we’ve already established Trump doesn’t know how to sell steak.
Re: Re:
Now that’s a well-done burn.
Re: Re: If Trump were CEO here, this advertising exec would be f
He sells more of a… different… bovine product.
I was just getting ready to go to the grocery store. Wanna guess what’s on my mind now?
Re: Re:
Saute some onions and green peppers, chop up the Steak-Umm as it cooks, mix in the veggies, melt provolone on top of it, salt and pepper to taste. Serve on sub rolls.
nice tasty cheesesteak that’s not terribly expensive.
The media is the munchies
One way or the other, steak-umm gives you something to chew on.
My dog welcomes steak and intelligent verbal intercouse
Be smart!
might just have to try some of that...
Damn, I’m WFH and practically living on sandwiches now that I have to eat my own cooking. I might just pick up a pack of this ‘near-meat’ food product, just to see how it tastes compared with endless ham-bo-sands. Every school kid should be learning what’s in those tweets… how come schools don’t teach ‘critical thinking’?
Re: might just have to try some of that...
Why would the people running things want peons that could think for themselves?
Re: might just have to try some of that...
The only lesson schools teach these days is that every child is a unique and beautiful snowflake who should win at everything (along with everyone else) and that their voice should be heard because every child already knows everything.
Re: might just have to try some of that...
"how come schools don’t teach ‘critical thinking’?"
Well, they’re supposed to. I remember that being an EXTREMELY popular buzzword when I was in school. But that’s basically all it was. Although I guess I’m not sure that I remember it ever being taught on its own really, just vague statements when some kid would ask what that meant when instructed to "think critically" when analyzing a sonnet or something. Not too sure the teachers get it either…. but the words surely appeared on all of the state-mandated standardized testing!
If I were a bit more cynical I might suggest that nobody understanding what those words really mean is intentional…throw the term at kids when they’re too young to really get it, so instead they attach to it some false/partial definition of whatever got them through the test — so something like just explaining in greater detail. Later in life, when they are asked to think critically about something, they’ll end up doing that instead.
Re: how come schools don't teach 'critical thinking'?
Possibly because it can be applied to lots of things … including political and religious beliefs?
Re: might just have to try some of that...
Nothing new in dumbing AMerican kids down-its on of the steps to owning the "machinery" under the Hegelian paradigm.
Right and left wing educators actually agree that his is a problem, and even radical lesbian, long time Democrat scholars too:
Prof. Camille Paglia on today’s stdents:
"They have no sense whatever of the destruction, of the great civilizations that rose and fell, and so on – and how arrogant people get when they’re in a comfortable civilization. They now have been taught to look around them to see defects in America – which is the freest country in the history of the world"
https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/article/paglia-dumbing-down-america-began-public-schools/
I used to eat Steak-umms. They weren’t bad. Fry them in a pan and they taste like thin steaks. Of course if you’re expecting them to taste like something that was cooked in a 5-star restaurant, you’ll be disappointed, but if you ever eat fast food, you’ll probably like Steak-umms. The only reason I haven’t bought them in a while is that I switched to a competing product, Steak-Eze, which are thicker frozen sandwich steaks that break apart better.
This: And for that we can blame my parents
You had great parents, knock it off….