Police Shut Down Hologram Concert Of Rapper Because They Don't Like His Lyrics; Pretty Clear First Amendment Problem

Free Speech

from the that's-not-how-this-works dept

The Chicago Tribune has a disturbing story about how the police in Hammond Indiana shut down an entire music festival because they didn’t like a particular rapper, Chief Keef, who appeared via hologram (supposedly to avoid arrest for some outstanding warrants in the mid-west). The police don’t even try to come up with some other bogus reason. They flat out admit that they didn’t want Keef to perform and thus they shut it down:

Hammond police Cmdr. Pat Vicari said the promoters were warned the concert would be shut down if Chief Keef performed.

“We spoke to the promoter several times, and they assured us (Chief Keef) would not be performing,” Vicari said. “Later, an officer working the show realized it was being streamed on one of the hip-hop sites, and promoters were warned again they would be shut down.?

Why? Because apparently politicians don’t like his lyrics:

Thomas M. McDermott Jr., the mayor of Hammond, said in an interview that his office became aware of the surprise performance, which was also streamed live online, through social media. All of the Craze Fest acts ? which included Riff Raff, Lil Bibby and Tink ? had been previously vetted because the event was held at a public park, he said.

?I know nothing about Chief Keef,? Mayor McDermott, 46, said. ?All I?d heard was he has a lot of songs about gangs and shooting people ? a history that?s anti-cop, pro-gang and pro-drug use. He?s been basically outlawed in Chicago, and we?re not going to let you circumvent Mayor Emanuel by going next door.?

The reference to Mayor Emanuel was to Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel blocking a similar concert in Chicago a week earlier, when Emanuel’s office declared Keef “an unacceptable role model.” Because, apparently, in Chicago, you’re only allowed to be a role model if the mayor’s office gives its stamp of approval:

Last weekend, a Chicago theater called off a similar show after representatives for Mayor Rahm Emanuel?s office deemed Chief Keef ?an unacceptable role model,? whose music ?promotes violence? and whose presence via hologram ?posed a significant public safety risk.?

Here’s the really crazy part, though. The concert itself was to protest violence, and was called a “Stop the Killing” benefit concert, in an effort to raise money for the families of two people that Keef knew who were recently killed in a shooting.

As Eugene Volokh notes, it’s difficult to see how this is anything but a First Amendment violation.

The government may impose reasonable content-neutral restrictions on speech in such venues, such as sound level restrictions, and may charge money for the use of the venues. But the government may not restrict speech because of its viewpoint, or the viewpoint that the speakers had expressed elsewhere, which seems to have happened here

He further points out that the “public safety” risk claims are not an acceptable reason to shut down the event either, pointing to Terminiello v. Chicago. Even beyond that, there were no reports of any actual threats or public safety issues at the event itself. And yes, Keef may have outstanding warrants, which would make it perfectly reasonable to have him arrested if he did show up, it still doesn’t explain why the concert was shut down.

Unless I?m missing something here, then, this is a pretty clear First Amendment violation on the part of the City of Hammond. And it seems to me that, in America, performances by controversial singers can?t be ?basically outlawed,? even ?in Chicago.

It will be interesting to see if Keef does anything about this. The hologram appearance was coordinated by Hologram USA, the company owned by wacky publicity hound billionaire Alki David, whose antics we’ve discussed in relation to his Aereo-clone streaming TV service FilmOn (not surprisingly, the concert was also being streamed live via… FilmOn). David immediately lashed out at the shutting down of the concert and rightly called out the First Amendment violation:

“Shame on the mayor and police chief of Hammond for shutting down a voice that can create positive change in a community in desperate need. And for taking away money that could have gone to help the victims’ families,” David said in a statement. “This was a legal event and there was no justification to shut it down besides your glaring disregard for the first amendment right to free speech.

Some have argued that Keef intentionally uses conflicts like this to get more publicity to market himself — and even if it’s true that doesn’t matter. Even if Keef is truly a horrible person in every way, the First Amendment isn’t supposed to only protect the speech of “good people.” It’s supposed to protect everyone. And yet it’s amazing how quickly some in power forget this.

Filed Under: alki david, chicago, chief keef, first amendment, free speech, hammond, indiana, pat vicari