Phillip 's Techdirt Comments

Latest Comments (111) comment rss

  • Reporter: E-Rated Kids' Game Unsafe For Kids Because The Internet Is Scary

    Phillip ( profile ), 09 Jul, 2013 @ 09:18am

    Why discuss game from 2 years ago?

    If they are going to make this dumb point, why are they doing so with a game that came out 2 years ago?

  • 'Gears Of War' Designer: Used Games Must Be Killed So Unsustainable Development Can Live

    Phillip ( profile ), 18 Jun, 2013 @ 02:23pm

    Re: Re: Re: Nintendo welcomes used games

    I wasn't saying it does. That is the only thing that is currently restricted. the latest shooter/sports/game etc they have one time use codes to try to capture money if you sell the game, and the new owner wants to play online.

    So with nintendo having shit for online support people don't care and the codes weren't worth the cost in infrastructure and support to implement. As far as I know there aren't any games on the 360/wii(u)/ps3 that tried to restrict single player. Some added "free" access to DLC or one time codes for "online" but that is it. This is all that people will be able to do with Sony or nintendo. Unless either company tried to stop a 3rd party there isn't DRM on either system is all I was pointing out since neither will do this with their games. Sony said they'll let publishers do whatever they think might work, and at the moment there is almost no 3rd part on the Wii U so it remains to be seen what if anything will happen

  • 'Gears Of War' Designer: Used Games Must Be Killed So Unsustainable Development Can Live

    Phillip ( profile ), 18 Jun, 2013 @ 07:49am

    Re: Nintendo welcomes used games

    Nintendo is the ONLY console maker this cycle not trying to block used games, at all. Unlike the PS4, the Wii U doesn't even support DRM to restrict used games, even if 3rd Parties wanted to (probably part of why they have so little 3rd Party support currently):

    Neither does Sony, they do not run or enable any DRM. They said they won't stop a publisher from trying to do a code based activation but it won't use Sony servers to enforce or enact this. This is the same way current system games try to restrict online access with online passes. However, pretty much all the publishers announced they are dropping online passes:

    Nintendo never had this publishers do this, because frankly Wii is and was terrible for online play. In trying to "protect" kids they created the worlds worst friends list with friend codes and horrible interfaces. They've made it slightly better with console codes instead of per-game codes but it is still not good.

  • 'Gears Of War' Designer: Used Games Must Be Killed So Unsustainable Development Can Live

    Phillip ( profile ), 18 Jun, 2013 @ 07:40am

    Re: Re: Used Games

    I don't like the xbone but Major Nelson addressed this question the other day, if you get banned you will not loose your games. Granted this is what they claim now. I will not fully believe it until it happens.

  • 'Gears Of War' Designer: Used Games Must Be Killed So Unsustainable Development Can Live

    Phillip ( profile ), 18 Jun, 2013 @ 07:34am

    Re: Re: Re: Used Games

    "Yeah I hadn't considered that. I guess I was primarily focused on GameStop. Correct me if I'm wrong on this but didn't Microsoft say they were going to allow you to transfer your game license? I believe you can only do it once which kind of sucks but at least its something (I realize it doesn't make up for it though)."

    Yes, Microsoft is letting you transfer a game once and it can not be transferred again, but this is a limitation on what you can do right now with your 360.

    "By this logic would you say that the developer only deserves a single sale of their game? Would you also say it's fair that if one person buys the game they have the right to make copies of that game and sell them outside of Wal-Mart? I don't really think its a fair analogy here as we are not discussing material objects that physically degrade over time such as a house or car. "

    So game discs don't get scratched up? Online communities don't die off? I loved Red Faction: Guerrilla, but the online community completely died off in less than 1 month. It would take 5-10 mins to find a single match. If you bought that game new or used later you would likely never experience the multiplier or at least much of it as there was no one to play with. Also, once the game is sold I'm not playing it there is still only one person playing it at a time.

    If you don't like cars/houses what about movies/music there are no restrictions on those do you think Netflix and Redbox should be eliminated they allow you to watch movies without paying for them. Many of which have the same or higher budgets as video games. What about HBO? they show you movies that you would otherwise have to purchase for yourself?

    "I still have to think about this some more and try to consider all angles. I didn't even think about private sellers. It is an interesting subject to say the least. Also, In my opinion, the publishers can go fuck themselves. They are basically middle-men like GameStop. I'm more concerned with the developers actually getting fair value for what they do. I myself am an aspiring independent (PC) game developer and I know just how much work it really takes to make these games. "

    Microsoft is requiring all games to have publishers or they won't be allowed on the xbone. Hence the next oddworld won't be available on it. Frequently developers get nothing or almost nothing from the sales. They get a check from the publisher and maybe they get a bonus or a small cut for certain sales.

    "I would totally be against passing legislation to prevent the sale of used games or anything like that. I do believe however, that the developers of the game should be able to do as they please with their software. If they want to restrict used game sales using built in methods I'm perfectly fine with that. "

    So your car manufacturer should tie your car to your DNA and if you want to transfer it you need to go to the dealership and pay them to transfer it to a new sucker. You don't have restrictions on your movies or cds and they keep chugging along while getting more pirated than console games.

    "I'm not even a console gamer so this doesn't really affect me so much. I do however, own 100+ games on Steam that I can't resell and that doesn't bother me at all because most of them I paid a fair price for (Not $60). I guess the point I'm trying to make is if we saw fairer pricing along with the elimination of the used games market (Steam-style) would people still feel as strongly? You say I'm entitled (I'm not sure what I'm pro porting to be entitled to) and yet you demand that software developers design their software in a way doesn't intrude on your right to resale. That seems more like an entitlement to me."

    Most people don't have issues with the digital games not being transferable and understand that. The issue is on the xbone if you buy a disc at Best Buy/GameStop/Amazon you can not transfer that disc. Sony and Microsoft both offer digital copies of games right now on their consoles that you can sell/trade/etc and no one cares. The entire issue is that Microsoft is trying to changes physical discs.

  • Reports Of Xbox One's Handling Of Used Games Mobilizes Playstation Fans

    Phillip ( profile ), 29 May, 2013 @ 02:13pm

    Re: Perspective

    That's fine if they want to sell the digital only game. The news that has come out so far is that they are doing this with the physical discs as well.
    Both microsoft and sony sell download only games that you can't sell, but if you want that option you can run out to Best Buy, target, etc and buy the physical disc.

  • Sorry, Having IMDB Accurately List Your Age Doesn't Entitle You To A Million Dollars

    Phillip ( profile ), 15 Apr, 2013 @ 09:33am


    They can't ask your age on an application. Which is the only part of this that makes some sense. But she created the mess that she is in.

  • Things You Don't See Every Day: MPAA Argues For Fair Use In Court

    Phillip ( profile ), 10 Apr, 2013 @ 09:47am

    Re: Could We Quote Them?

    surprised they actually realized this can hurt them as well, but very glad they did. Hopefully, if they win this will help others in their fair use claims as well.

  • Copyright Maximalist Disney Accused Of Copying Artist's Painting On Cosmetic Bag

    Phillip ( profile ), 09 Apr, 2013 @ 02:51pm

    Re: Response

    I agree, while the concept might be derivative, using her exact art - color is not really derivative its outright copying. I agree the t-shirt is perfectly fine but the bag seems highly questionable.

  • Will People Trust Google's New 'Note' Keeping Service After Reader Shutdown?

    Phillip ( profile ), 21 Mar, 2013 @ 12:03pm

    Re: Remember google notebook

    Yep, don't even care what Keep is or does. Google will just shut it down soon.

    Wave, Notebook, iGoogle, Reader, and many more

  • Do You Live In The Constitution-Free Zone Of The US?

    Phillip ( profile ), 12 Feb, 2013 @ 01:50pm


    Depends how DHS would see it though.
    Generally things come into play at the land, otherwise the entire coastal part is wrong since international waters start about 12 miles out (
    as a result everything should only be affected 88 miles inland instead of the 100 they are showing, if this is the case.

  • FAA Facing More Pressure To Change Its Rules On Electronic Device Usage

    Phillip ( profile ), 03 Jan, 2013 @ 01:34pm


    that doesn't even get into the fact that many devices are actually left on unintentionally in bags or pockets.

    Plus they make you "turn off" ereaders, but you just have to put cell phones and devices in flight mode. I'm pretty sure smartphones and most other devices put off way more EMI than an ereader which only really uses power to change pages.

  • This Goes Beyond Tablets: Apple, Amazon & Google Are Betting On Economic Philosophies

    Phillip ( profile ), 13 Sep, 2012 @ 01:20pm

    mostly true except on all their video conent

    what jeff said mostly applies but yet there is still no way to watch Amazon video on none Kindle Fire's.

    You can get music, books, audiobooks on pretty much any device. However, if you want to watch digital video on a handheld device it currently only exists on the Fire and has for the last year. If this is truly how they feel they need to release apps for other handheld devices.

    It can't just be licensing holding them back I can watch amazon on several other devices (Sony TV, Sony Bluray Player, Xbox 360) but no iDevices or Androids that aren't put out by amazon.

  • Judge Quickly Approves Ebook Pricing Settlement; Says It's In The Public Interest To Stop Price Fixing

    Phillip ( profile ), 06 Sep, 2012 @ 01:19pm

    Re: Re:

    Not true, that's the cost to duplicate it. It costs amazon x.xx per copy to the publisher plus "about 0" to themselves for storage/bandwidth. So as long as they are charging x.xx + 0/y they are making marginal cost

  • HBO Go Goes Everywhere… Except Your TV Set

    Phillip ( profile ), 30 Aug, 2012 @ 07:00am

    Re: Re:

    as pointed out above it also works fine on an xbox360

  • Apple/Samsung Jurors Admit They Finished Quickly By Ignoring Prior Art & Other Key Factors

    Phillip ( profile ), 27 Aug, 2012 @ 12:27pm

    Re: Re: Re: Re: Jury Nullification in action

    except as has been pointed out multiple times it is used in favor of a defendant, not in favor of a claimant against a defendant as is the case here.

  • Apple/Samsung Jurors Admit They Finished Quickly By Ignoring Prior Art & Other Key Factors

    Phillip ( profile ), 27 Aug, 2012 @ 12:24pm

    Re: Re: Re:

    Brilliant idea, instead of a jury of people since people aren't the peers of Samsung or Apple.

    The jury can be made up of other corporations.
    We'll have a jury made up of 12 corporations in the technology field.

  • An Explanation For Why Verizon Is Driving DSL Users To Competitors' Cable Lines

    Phillip ( profile ), 26 Jul, 2012 @ 09:55am

    Re: Re:

    except they are talking about trying to sell this to people in the future to replace their home DSL/Cable broadband. 10 gigs at home is nothing I go through that in a couple days

  • Movie Showing How Music Can Help Dementia Patients Held Up… By The Difficulty In Licensing The Music

    Phillip ( profile ), 24 Jul, 2012 @ 01:31pm


    I agree but perhaps the deal they had to sign to get it distributed in theaters required the delay, since we all know that theaters think that the delay helps them and are afraid of anything else.

  • Viacom Uses Fans As Hostages: Blocks Daily Show, Colbert Streams For Everyone To Spite DirecTV

    Phillip ( profile ), 13 Jul, 2012 @ 12:50pm

    Re: Re: Re:

    it's a daily news show who cares about old content, they still have clips up which would be about all i care about and they still have episodes on hulu, so still a non-issue

Next >>